Repository navigation
[Rewrite P0] Protocol currency audit: NIP registry vs nostream at capture #861
Description
Parent: #860
Milestone: Phase 0: Protocol currency audit
Host: chappie · Expected cost: $80
Diff the Nostr protocol as of the capture date against what nostream implements, and produce the authoritative NIP list the rewrite must satisfy.
- Fetch the NIP registry (noscl/nips repo) as of 2026-10-15T00:00:00Z; list every NIP, its status (final/draft/obsolete) and one-line summary
- Diff against
supportedNips(25 NIPs: 1,2,3,4,9,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,20,22,25,28,33,40,42,43,44,45,50,65,77) — for each gap decide: must-have for parity, opportunistic add, or out of scope; record the decision - Check NIPs that changed since nostream implemented them (e.g. NIP-11 metadata fields, NIP-42 auth flow, NIP-77 negentropy status) — flag behavioural deltas with NIP-spec citations
- Check the 24 post-capture commits (through 2026-10-15T00:00:00Z) for protocol-affecting changes (measured: NIP-77 wire protocol landing in 7409006/7409006-class commits, settings URL validation 48fe9c4)
- Output:
docs/rewrite/nip-parity.mdin the repo — table of NIP → status in nostream → delta → rewrite disposition; the disposition rows become issues in Phase 2 or explicit "not implementing" notes
Acceptance: every one of the 25 advertised NIPs has a disposition; every registry NIP marked final/active has a decision; the deltas carry citations to the NIP text.
Activity
chappie-daemon commentedon Oct 17, 2026
Outcome — escalated, awaiting review on the PR.
decision.mdin.factory/jobs/001-nip-audit/records what was and was not reviewed.factory-spans.tscounted 24 of 30 sessions ($3.30 of $3.71) — it silently drops agent sessions it cannot resolve to the orchestrator (recon, spec, four scopers here). Corrected figure and method incost.md.chappie-daemon commentedon Oct 17, 2026
Merged as 526054b (#872): docs/rewrite/nip-parity.md, 99 dispositions, 11 delta sections, 11 Phase 2 items. Greptile's three P2 findings were fixed in dc5b32a before the merge (NIP-09 a-tag deletion, NIP-28 kind 41 replaceability, NIP-11 test coverage), threads resolved, oracle PASS. Actual cost $3.71 vs $80 expected (0.046x) — calibration recorded in #860.